A Scholarly Proof: Leadership in the Zuhur of Allah’s Names
Why Only Those Who Experience the Manifestation Can Guide Others
Premise 1: Leadership Requires Presence of Knowledge
-
Reasoning: To guide others in recognition (zuhur) of Allah’s Names, a leader must themselves fully experience that recognition. One cannot manifest in others what is absent in the self.
Premise 2: Zuhur Requires Recitation and Writing
-
From Previous Proof:
-
Recitation (dhikr) awakens the qalb and connects it to the rūḥ.
-
Writing (kitābah) preserves and stabilizes knowledge in the intellect.
-
-
Conclusion: Without these acts, the zuhur of the Names does not exist in the servant.
Premise 3: Leadership in Zuhur Requires Zuhur in Self
-
Reasoning: A leader cannot transmit divine recognition that they have not themselves manifested. Transmission requires prior manifestation in the leader’s heart and intellect.
Synthesis: Necessary Criterion for Leadership
-
Activation: Leader must perform dhikr to awaken the heart.
-
Stabilization: Leader must write to preserve and fix knowledge.
-
Logical Necessity: Without experiencing zuhur themselves, one cannot guide others.
Hence: Recitation + Writing = Necessary Criterion for Leadership in Zuhur
Supporting Qur’anic Principle
“Recite in the Name of your Lord who created, Who taught by the pen.” (Qur’an 96:1–4)
-
Recitation awakens → Enables leadership readiness
-
Writing preserves → Ensures sustained transmission
Conclusion
Anyone who seeks to lead in the zuhur of Allah’s Names must first manifest them in their own heart and intellect. Absence of these preconditions renders leadership impossible.
Comments